Posted: March 6th, 2023

Explain the advantages and challenges of supranational courts Comparative Criminal Justice Systems.

Supranational courts, such as the European Court of Justice (ECJ), represent a new type of judicial structure which has been established in recent decades with the objective to strengthen and protect human rights across countries. Through their rulings, these institutions can harmonize laws and regulations between states, ultimately promoting better coordination and cooperation among nations. The potential benefits of supranational courts lie at both national and international levels; they are seen as useful tools for states to develop comparative criminal justice systems by allowing them to learn from one another’s legal experiences. However, it is important to recognize that there may also be some challenges associated with this type of institution.

One clear advantage associated with supranational courts is the ability for them to ensure compliance with international laws across countries. These institutions operate above state borders and are therefore able to enforce agreements made between different nations on issues such as human rights or trade policies (Chin & Waters 2016). This helps create a more uniform level of standards internationally which can benefit all member-states involved. Moreover, such institutions can assist in resolving conflicts between states without requiring direct diplomatic action or military intervention – something that could save money and time for governments (Sayer 2012).

See also  Identify the most important Supreme Court cases and executive actions and their impact on law and on our society.

Furthermore, supranational courts offer an additional tool for developing comparative criminal justice systems which allow countries to learn from each other’s experiences in terms of legal procedures and practices (Chin & Waters 2016). By comparing how cases have been handled within different contexts, judges may gain a better understanding of how various national law enforcement models approach similar issues, thereby enhancing their own knowledge base when making decisions in courtrooms (Trubek 2014). Additionally, lawyers representing different countries can work together on transnational disputes where common interests intertwine; through this collaboration they become familiarized with one another’s customs while simultaneously aiding in finding solutions tailored specifically towards the context presented (Aleinikoff 2015).

See also  Compare and contrast UCR and NCVS with respect to the type of crime data they collect and how they collect it.

Explain the advantages and challenges of supranational courts Comparative Criminal Justice Systems.

However there are also some critiques concerning supranational court systems which must not be overlooked. To begin with, due to their independent status outside any particular jurisdiction these kinds of bodies may act without proper accountability or transparency (O’Boyle 2008); additionally excessive power could lead certain members-states allocate too much authority over others leading potentially undemocratic outcomes if left unchecked (Sayer 2012). Furthermore there is debate about whether the rulings issued by supra-national entities should take precedence over domestic ones when local laws conflict; some suggest that giving priority to foreign regulations undermines sovereignty values while others argue that this very same concept allows equal access between citizens regardless of nationality permitting greater fairness overall among individuals living abroad(Aleinikoff 2015) .

See also  Describe one innovative health care delivery model that incorporates an interdisciplinary care delivery team.

In conclusion then it appears evident that though having many advantages ,supranational court systems do come along certain challenges too; future research should explore ways by which these obstacles might be mitigated whilst still preserving the basic tenets upon which international cooperation was originally founded upon .

Expert paper writers are just a few clicks away

Place an order in 3 easy steps. Takes less than 5 mins.

Calculate the price of your order

You will get a personal manager and a discount.
We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price: